2017 All-VISAA Division I
First Team Offense
Wideout: Dequece Carter, Woodberry Forest
Athlete: Khalid Thomas, Woodberry Forest
First Team Defense
Linebacker: Iosefa Pua’auli, Fork Union
Second Team Offense
Wideout: Logan Justice, Fork Union
Fullback/Tight End: Kyle Bilodeau, Woodberry Forest
Second Team Defense
Defensive Line: Warren Matthews, Woodberry Forest
Defensive back: Cameron Hill, Woodberry Forest
2017 All-VISAA Division II
First Team Offense
Quarterback: John Huemme, Covenant School
Running back: Sammy Fort, Blue Ridge
Wideout: Jonas Sanker, Covenant
Offensive line: Will Edelson, STAB
Kick Returner: Myles Ward, STAB
First Team Defense
Defensive Line: Will Edelson, STAB
Linebacker: Aden Britton, Blue Ridge
Defensive back: Jonas Sanker, Covenant
Second Team Offense
Running back: Donovan Jackson, Covenant
Wideout: Cameron Carr, Blue Ridge
Wideout: Myles Ward, STAB
Second Team Defense
Punt Returner: Myles Ward, STAB